| Name | Reason |
| 1. Nun | Bricked up alive |
| 2. Monk | Hanged or beheaded |
| 3-4. One or two coachmen | Hanged or beheaded |
| 5. Simon of Sudbury | Beheaded, 14 June 1381 |
| 6. Sir Edward Waldegrave | Died, Tower of London, 1 September
1561 Congregation had adopted revised prayer book |
| 7. John Deeks | Obnoxious minister from 1642-60 |
| 8. Loyalist cavalier | Ran from battle on Borley Green Found and killed |
| 9. Catholic priest - Dominic or Enoch | Crucified in church yard, dumped down well |
| 10. His lover, a nun | Murdered |
| 11. Marie Lairre | Strangled by Charles Waldegrave, 17 May 1667 |
| 12. Arabella Waldegrave | Stuart spy Murdered by mother, Henrietta 1697 |
| 13. Henrietta Waldegrave | Government spy Murdered by Nicholas Waldegrave, 1730 |
| 14. Screaming girl | Dropped out of the Blue Room window |
| 15-16. Two coachmen | Executed for murder |
| 17. Katie Boreham | Strangled by Harry, Easter 1888 |
| 18. Harry Bull | Poisoned by wife, Ivy. Promised to throw mothballs. |
| 19. Lionel Foyster | Poisoned |
| 20. Harry Price | Defamed. Clairvoyant Lilian Bailey received a message from Price saying, "The rectory is definitely haunted. Borley will prove itself and I will be vindicated, even if I have to go there and manifest myself." |